About Me

"Use every man after his desert, and who should 'scape whipping?"
Showing posts with label London cycle deaths. Show all posts
Showing posts with label London cycle deaths. Show all posts

Friday, 8 June 2018

Cyclists killed on London's streets: a new Ghost Bike commemorates another death in Deptford


It feels like an undeclared war in London between drivers and cyclists has broken out again, with three cyclists killed in the last month - all in the Greenwich-Deptford area of south east London.

The first two cyclist deaths on London's roads in 2018 were both on the A206 between the Greenwich Naval College and the Blackwall Tunnel roundabout: that deadly route to Woolwich. According to the report in the Evening Standard, both were males, 46 and 37, and both were killed by lorries, on May 9 and May 18 respectively.

Cyclists' groups have campaigned for cycle lanes to be built here, but the authority - Greenwich - has failed to take action.

Then, last Sunday, June 3 - ironically, World Bicycle Day - a male cyclist in his fifties died in a shocking and puzzling incident at the junction of Childers Street and Rolt Street, SE8. This was a hit-and-run incident, at a junction where traffic-calming measures and a new supposedly cyclist-friendly route had only recently opened.

The case is under police investigation. A 37-year-old man was arrested on Wednesday on a charge of causing death by dangerous driving, then was released.

By Thursday, one of the white Ghost Bikes had been chained to the signpost at the scene of this death. I know this corner well, often cycling to this exact point, to visit the Acme studios in the former Propeller Factory on Childers Street. It's only in the last few months that many of the streets and pavements around here have been re-paved and traffic calming measures introduced.

It seems the bike became trapped under the car, which was then driven up Childers Street to the next junction. Unable to dislodge the bike, the driver was then seen to run off on foot, abandoning the car. You can see the scratches gouged into the recently-resurfaced road by the trapped bike. It is a chilling sight, when you realise that at the time these scratches were made the rider was dying on the street, despite efforts to help him from several passers-by.

Rolt Street is part of a well-known rat-run for drivers trying to beat the traffic in the Surrey Quays - Deptford - New Cross triangle. Locals say the new one-way system is often ignored by motorists, and that the council has often been told this: even after the death, cars and vans were shooting through that narrow one-way lane in the wrong direction.

There's no point in going on. Except to say - unfortunately - that no London cyclist will be surprised by this horrific event. The levels of car/van/lorry driver aggression have been increasing: anger seems to be in the foul air we all have to breathe. Cars screech to a halt at junctions, their nasty bumpers two or three feet out into the cycle lane - they can't wait for the cyclists to pass, they bristle.

Each one of these deaths, like any other unnatural, unnecessary killing, creates terrible ripples of grief which extend far beyond family.

We're in a city suffering creeping death by vehicle pollution. Air pollution, visual pollution, stress pollution, noise pollution. The power-brokers are trying to keep the motorists happy, even when they know it is essential to discourage private drivers,  and to shift the balance towards more sustainable public transport.

Each cyclist killed on London streets is a victim of political decisions and business decisions. Such as the decision to allow hundreds of ready-mix cement and tipper trucks on to the narrow streets of central London, as they rush to feed the greedy construction sites of the City, Nine Elms, Blackfriars, Elephant and Castle, Old Street, Waterloo, Chelsea Barracks etc etc etc...Yes, just to build more unaffordable luxury apartments in tower blocks which add more visual pollution to the skyline. And whose occupants - if they ever move in - will probably soon be blasting down your street in their obese Maseratis and Range Rovers.

For many years, the groups who fight for safer streets for all have marked each cycle death with a white bike - a ghostly reminder to all passing traffic of a horrific event.

I look out for these, knowing the locations of many white bikes within a few minutes ride from here. Recently, one has disappeared - the one on Lavender Hill, Battersea, opposite the Police Station. It marked the spot where 32-year-old Lucia Ciccioli was killed at 7.54am on October 24, 2016, by a massive truck, which appeared to be delivering plaster-board to building sites.

Maybe this memorial has been removed at the request of the family of the victim. But if not - why has it gone? To make life easier for somebody? If that's the case, I'd say it was a dismal move.

I wish these  Ghost Bikes would remain in situ for ever: concrete them in, reinforce them; make sure they get in people's way, make sure they cause drivers' heads to turn and consciences to start pricking them.

Maybe in 100 years people would look at them in disbelief that such fragile, elegant machines could have been so much at the mercy of speeding lumps of metal, oil and plastic, filling the air with their toxic stench and their hideous blaring horns and roaring engines. And so often carrying just one or a couple of people, unnecessarily, very slowly, to schools or shops.






Friday, 28 October 2016

The death of another cyclist, this time on Lavender Hill, hits home like nothing before

A young woman cyclist has been killed near this terrible junction where Lavender Hill meets Elspeth Road: three lanes into one as drivers ignore the left and right filters and use it like a drag-race grid to be first at the next set of lights. Re-design
this junction, tame the traffic, ban the six-axle lorries, police it!
Ever 15 minutes or so on Monday, BBC Radio London's traffic news warned drivers to steer clear of the Battersea-Clapham area because of a serious accident, and that part of Lavender Hill had been closed by police for investigations.

Later that day the accident moved from traffic to mainstream news: it became clear that a cyclist had been involved in an incident with a large truck, and that the cyclist had died at the scene.

A bit later the news websites changed the word "cyclist" to "woman".

A woman had died - been killed - in an accident on Lavender Hill involving a truck leased by a company known as British Gypsum, a big supplier of plasterboard and related building products.

Early reports included quotes from a witness who'd seen the truck with a bike stuck under the front wheels, driving along, with the driver apparently not realising anything had happened, until waved down by pedestrians. According to the Evening Standard the lorry eventually pulled up about 150 yards on from the point of impact, which was close to Battersea Police Station.

So why am I writing about this horrific incident? Because I have become so aware of the danger of huge trucks being driven so fast along these roads in recent years, I have just been dreading something like this happening.

-  Because I live less than a half a mile from where this accident happened.

-  Because I am a cyclist and have cycled up and down Lavender Hill most days over the past 35 years.

-  Because I must have past the point where the 32-year old Lucia Ciccioli was killed on Monday, literally thousands of times. I passed there twice today, which is when I took these photos. 

And because on one occasion, I avoided being hit by a lorry by such a small margin that I know I will never forget that sensation of a brush with death.

It was 8 years ago, at a point just after the crossroads with Elspeth Road. In fact, within a few metres from where this poor young woman died. I was cycling west towards Clapham Junction. I pulled away from the junction, where three lanes of traffic suddenly become one. Traffic at this point is competing for position in the queues that always build up on Lavender Hill.

As I crossed the junction a big refuse truck from the company that does the bins for Wandsworth Council stormed up behind me. It wasn't merely close to me, the flange of its white painted front wheel arch touched my right arm. If I had continued on my course I would have been hit by the front wheel of that lorry.

Instead I made myself fall to the left, into a set of railings that have now, I think been removed. At the same time I rammed on the brakes, and sort of collapsed into the railings, without  any serious injury, but bruised and shaking like hell. The truck surged off into the distance, at what seemed like a speed well above the 30mph limit, and the driver clearly hadn't noticed me. I was so freaked out that I started to shout out obscenities at the top of my voice, but no cars or trucks stopped. A couple of pedestrians asked if I was OK and I realised that I was OK.

I was so lucky. A few years later I was knocled off my bike by a car in the same road, near the Queenstown Road junction, broke some bones but I survivied. I am so lucky.

No-one can really help the family and friends of this young woman, killed on her way to work at a new job on a cold south London morning. It is heart-breaking, as is every death on our hopelessly congested roads. But this one, it just got to me, and to many others, it seems.


The only thing we can try to do is to try to convert this tragedy into an energy to change things, to make such tragedies less frequent in future.

And yet, even now, after 10 years or more of efforts to make these gigantic trucks safer for other road users in heavily populated, mixed-traffic areas, these hideous incidents keep on occurring. What can we do, what can those with power do? Well, here are some ideas:
  • Look at the size of these trucks, measure their speeds.
  •  Check out the drivers' delivery schedules and  how they are paid. They have to get through dreadful traffic on congested streets in unreasonably short spaces of time. 
  • Crack down on the firms - and they are often suppliers to the construction industries - who impose these schedules and penalties.
  • Re-route heavy trucks - a vehicle this size shouldn't be on this road. And certainly not at 7.54am rush-hour time. It's absurd. What's the point of the Mayor and those powers if he never uses them?


Today (Thursday), Evening Standard journalist Rosamund Irwin writes about this tragic incident, as a fellow cyclist who also uses this street on her way to work. She's compassionate and, when it comes to trying to stop this carnage, she makes some very sensible suggestions. The Mayor Sadiq Khan's proposals to ban the most dangerous lorries from London streets is fine - but it will takes several years to implement. She wonders if this could be speeded up, perhaps by incentivising haulage companies, perhaps offering a discount on the congestion charge if they modify their trucks.

I understand her point - but it is coming form the wrong direction.  These companies are making huge profits from supplying the vast numbers of building and regeneration and transport projects in central London. We need a much tougher stance to protect the interests of all road users from these thundering, murderous vehicles. I say this as a car driver (and road-tax payer) as well as a pedestrian, cyclist and local resident, sick of the stink and the damage caused by this relentless procession of huge lorries.

What is  such a huge truck allowed on Lavender Hill anyway? Surely the parallel route along the north side of Clapham Common would allow more space and less congestion? But no, strangely, this road - the one you might think would be the logical trunk route towards the A3 at Wandsworth - is the one with traffic calming measures. Is that to do with all those grand houses and posh private schools
that line the edges of the common? There you have the space to widen a road; maybe build a bridge for pedestrians. Get these speeding monstrosities off Lavender Hill!









Thursday, 25 June 2015

Questions and theories about the trucks that are killing cyclists on London streets

Caution, keep clear: eight fat wheels accelerating fast from the rmc site at Silverthorne road.


On Monday 22 June 2015 a 26-year-old woman became the eighth cyclist to die on a London street this year - and all but one of them was killed by heavy goods vehicles.

The woman killed yesterday outside the Bank of England died in now grimly familiar circumstances - crushed beneath the front wheels of left-turning tipper truck at a road junction.

How often do we have to read that terrible phrase: "crushed by the wheels of a left-turning tipper truck"? And how many more times will we have to read it this year, this decade?

There's little doubt the deaths will continue while London's construction business booms, and cycling to work becomes more and more necessary for cash-strapped workers. So that at the same times of day, every day, there are thousands of each of these totally incompatible forms of transport hurtling down the same  narrow, complex web of streets towards the same central honeypot.

Pundits are busy speculating why so many women are being killed this way in central London (six out of the eight deaths this year were of women, mostly young women).

But of the all the theories put forward and all the angry debate, no one seems to have asked two questions.

First - when they say a tipper truck, what precisely do they mean? Are they always really tipper trucks? It would be helpful if media reports were more specific in each case. There are many shapes and sizes of tipper trucks, but some of the newest ones seem to be incredibly powerful and to accelerate like sports cars.

Second - how often do they consider the nature of the construction business, and the sort of pressure drivers of these trucks are  working under to deliver their materials at the right time??

Photo: Bill Hicks
The notorious Walkie-Talkie tower: how many truck loads of
cement, steel, glass and plastic went into building this
monstrosity? And how safely were they driven to the site?
Look at a building like the (hideous) Walkie-Talkie in Fenchurch street, imagine how much concrete,
steel and glass went into its construction, how many truck loads had to be negotiated through the narrow streets of the square mile. And how many tipper trucks to clear all that excavated mud, stone and debris from demolished buildings on the site.

Look at the way the construction industry deals with the logistics of such a site: material shave to be there at exactly the right time, there's no space to keep stockpiles of steel. And above all the concrete on which all these vast buildings rest has to be poured within 90 minutes of its mixing.

The lorries which have scared me most often are the massive four-axle ready-mix trucks with their giant rotating barrels on the back, but I guess that's because I live close to one of the main ready-mix supply depots.

Here the just-in-time method is at its most acute - they fill up with ready mix at one of the many depots in zone 2, then they have a very limited time to get to the building site.

If you don't trust me, check out some of the business school papers on the topic. For example,  this one from the University of California, Berkeley (1999), Iris D. Tommelein1 and Annie En Yi Li2's paper, Just-in-Time Concrete Delivery: Mapping Alternatives for Vertical Supply Chain Integration. 

As these authors point out, "Since concrete should be placed no later than ninety minutes after the addition of water, travel from the batch plant to a site should not take much more than half an hour or so. A plant’s operating radius therefore tends to be limited based on the nature and condition of haul roads."

They of course were not thinking of the road conditions in London. If a driver is delayed to the point that the load is useless, what happens? Do the driver get just the same pay, whatever? Are they incentivised? Are there bonuses, reasons for pushing just a bit harder to get there at exactly the right time?

It's just a thought. Some of the other suggestions for this tragic death toll are equally plausible: for example, that females tend to be less aggressive and more careful, hanging back at junctions, but being invisible to the driver, become victims of their own caution.

Tipper truck at Battersea Power Station
Is Boris going to restrict the movements of these trucks? Is Parliament going to legislate to stop the use of unsafe trucks or unsafe incentives for drivers? Probably not in the next five years. Despite the big noise about safer cycle paths, there's clearly not much progress in other areas where a little rearrangement of traffic could make a big difference.

It's clear that the safest way to deal with traffic lights in heavy London traffic is either to jump the light - to move off when the pedestrian green lights ar eon, say: or at least to push to the front, occupy the centre of the lane, and move off in front of the first bus, car or truck.

Either that or stay well back. Having cycled in London for about 40 years, I've come to the conclusion that the best way of not becoming another statistic is to ensure you make eye contact with every driver potentially crossing your path. This worked for me quite well until August 2006 when I was hit by a right-turning car, straight in front of me on a main road. I had looked at the man driving, he seems dot see me, I accelerated, he accelerated faster than me. Bang.


Thursday, 14 November 2013

Another cycling death - and still the trucks race through city streets

Five cyclists die in London in 9 days - and three are on a so-called "Cycle Superhighway"
Five cyclists killed in nine days - the latest this morning on the Whitechapel High Street, a stretch of the now-notorious cycle super-highway 2.

They keep saying, the numbers killed on London streets are proportionately lower than ten years ago - but  ten years ago, few cyclists wore crash helmets. And five deaths in one city in nine days is desperate, especially when three of them were on the same so-called "cycle superhighway" between Aldgate and Stratford.

Many factors have been suggested. Last year, when there was a terrible spate of young women cyclists being killed, it was mooted that maybe it was the lack of experience or street confidence that was to blame. Some also cited the recklessness and apparent sense of immortality exhibited by younger gung-ho cyclists. London Mayor Boris Johnson himself called for cyclists to be more alert to danger on the BBC Radio 4 news this evening.

No such excuses hold good for more recent deaths - the 62-year-old hospital porter killed on the Mile End Road last Tuesday, for example, had no chance at all - he was hit from behind and crushed under the truck's front wheel.

The favoured theory is that the poor field of vision of drivers of huge dumper trucks and buses is the big problem. Surely they have angled mirrors to see the curb - or surely they would not be allowed on the road.

I'd add another factor - that so many of their drivers are working under heavy pressure to deliver on time, an appalling imposition for anyone trying to negotiate the hideously crowded streets of greater London. Cycle down Silverthorne Road, Battersea , to the junction with Queenstown Road. You pass on the busiest cement works in London, with a constant stream of massive trucks with those revolving green and yellow mixers on the back. They swarm around these small streets like big fat wasps, in , fill, out again in two minutes flat, no time to stop longer, feeding all those building sites along Nine Elms and further afield.

I've been both a commuting and recreational cyclist in central London since 1978. I've had two accidents involving broken bones - one of which was my fault, the other the fault of a right-turning driver who simply didn't see me and accelerated across my path.

 I've had two incredibly close shaves - once between a converging bus and lorry on Highbury Corner in 1981, the other between a light-jumping refuse truck and steel railing on Lavender Hill in 2010.

I was tempted to write a "how to stay alive" list of advice to cyclists new to London, but I know that quite often you will simply be in a position where there's nothing you can do.

However much care you take to make eye-contact with every driver emerging from side streets or turning left at traffic lights, however good you are anticipating hazards, avoiding danger spots, however careful you are always to use lights and high-vis clothing - there will come a time when someone in a nippy vehicle, on a tight time-schedule, will whip round a corner or between lanes of traffic and you will be in  the way, and in that case, all you can do is pray; you might live and you might die.