About Me

"Use every man after his desert, and who should 'scape whipping?"

Tuesday, 31 March 2026

Strange but true: many shoppers actually prefer self-checkout (and other weird reports from south London's retail frontline)

 Asda, Clapham Junction, on a busy Sunday afternoon, last week or any other time of year.

There's a huge queue of  mainly young people - the type who  used to be called yuppies but who might now be called gen Z-ers or whatever - waiting to use the self-check out tills. 

Most wearing sports kit of some sort or other, some clutching multi-packs of beer, energy drinks and crisps. Maybe hoping to get them home before some big match kicks off on tv.

Clutching my own haul of bananas, pitta bread, and a kilo of Lancashire Farm yogurt, I am  surprised and happy to find much shorter queues at the two or three remaining real check-outs, with a human being at the till. The further you walk from the exit, the shorter the queue. I am through in three minutes, and have a brief chat with the check-out person into the bargain.

If you think this was a freak inversion of normal experience, think again. Over the past year  I've benefitted from this phenomenon dozens of times. Not just in Asda, but all the supermarkets I ever use, even the Germans. 

Sainsburys on Clapham High Street is, at certain times of day, a reliable example. This medium-size supermarket is where two separate SW4 demographics meet but never coalesce. Well-off, youngish professionals rub shoulders with mainly less well-off residents of nearby social housing estates.

In the former group, the young men _– sports shorts and sporting that uniquely unattractive hairstyle of the moment – were joining an already  massive queue for the self-checkout tills. 

Perhaps they don't even realise that there are two or three human check-out tills at the back of the store. Here are much shorter queues, often old people (like me) who have an instinctive dislike of machines that tell you off.  Also people who for whatever reason don't have debit or credit cards let alone mobile phone payment apps.

Not saying these yuppie types are bad or unpleasant people - simply that their upbringing and London lifestyles seems to turn them against engaging with "others" (ie not their sort) in the flesh. Maybe some are scarred by Covid (but these are surely the ones who rarely even go out to shop, but stay home and  have everything, even a single bottle of Heinz Tomato ketchup, delivered to their door). 

This is perhaps a trivial example of a deeper, longer-term change in behaviour. Reluctance to even think of wasting time, and assuming that anything involving touch-screen technology is bound to be quicker and more efficient than the old ways. The terrible risk of becoming engaged in small talk with some grubby old man in the queue (that's me, obviosuly). Getting stuck behind the mum with a clutch of lively kids, who's having problems with her Nectar vouchers; being silently judged by others for your purchase of a twelve-pack of lager and those tubes of crisps (that's just my prejudice talking).

Or maybe it's just herd instinct - seeing a long queue of your type of people, and joining it.

Long may this phenomenon persist as it means other shoppers can enjoy a bit of human interaction and get throuhg more quickly.

But self-checkout continues to expand, with many smaller branches rarely having any staffed tills. The retailers prefer machines to people; they are so much cheaper. 

Another trend seems to subliminally encourage people to buy more.  Two or three of the shops I used to use have now got rid of nearly all the small baskets in favour of enlarged, deformed plastic baskets with wheels and handles.  

These new contraptions block aisles and other shoppers trip over them. They're just as annoying as the flotillas of wheeled suitcases that trundle across the departure zones of all big railway stations, airports, etc. 

But they're there, and everyone except me and a few other stubborn users of old-school baskets, have accepted them.

Reminder to self: you are just a relic of a bye-gone age. Don't worry about these things!

Context: First versions of this post were written soon after the covid lockdowns, when shoppers were still re-learning the rules of social interaction. Like the majority of stuff written for this blog, I didn't publish, thinking it too trivial and subjective, too much reeking of prejudice.

Ironically, the day I chose to put it out into the open air, large numbers of kids were dropping into supermarkets on Clapham High Street and avoiding all the check-outs, whether self or staffed. These end of term disturbances  on Saturday and Tuesday seemed to me like a bigger version of what happens on that stretch of the high street every school day at abut 4pm, when bunches of demob-happy kids crowd around bus-stops and the fast-food outlets. Similar surges have been seen all over London over recent years. 

The location - one of the most dismal High Streets in London – sees diferent but equally disturbing displays of anti-scoial behaviour every Friday and Saturday evening, when the ya-hoo stag and hen night crowds descend. It's  like a laboratory experiment for sociologists. That big shiny new M & S oppostie Sainsburys is emblematic of the Clapham disease. The shop is for well-heeled young professionals with lots of cash but not much time. I wonder if that space had been taken over by Lidl instead of M & S, would we have seen such enthusiastic crowds of non-paying customers on Tuesday evening? 




 

Sunday, 22 March 2026

No, I don't have a "smart speaker" at home. And I never will, thanks very much.

What is the four-word sequence most often repeated across all BBC radio stations?

I don't have proof for this, but I'd say the phrase that has struck my much-abused eardrums more than any other over the past two years is, "ask your smart speaker..."

This message is repeated so regularly, and with such urgency, across so many stations (I've even heard versions of it on Radio 3 recently) that I can't help feeling someone at the BBC is on extremely good terms with some consumer electronics suppliers.

Why else would they be urging us to use these mysterious products? Surely if we're already listening to BBC local radio, Radio 4, or whatever, you don't need a "smart" anything to find it again? My sad experiences with any other "smart" technology (ie, phones) suggests the clever speaker would almost certainly serve up the wrong channel and refuse to find what I really wanted.

I do remember, well over a decade ago, being invited round to drinks with some former neighbours who wanted to show off their latest gadget - a sound system with "Alexa", an early version of this smart speaker craze. The entertainment we would have asking Alexa to find some obscure piece of music, then crying with laughter at the unlikely alternatives it played for us, lasted for roughly the first bottle of wine. And that was it. 

I could not then imagine that, all these years later, I would be driven mad being urged, every half hour or so,  to ask one of these devices to find one of three stations I listen to most often. 

I might of course ask it to find me the most recent edition of Point of View featuring a favourite such as Will Self or A L Kennedy. Would it tell me the BBC scrapped this gem of a programme over a year ago? Never has ten minutes of radio airtime been more intelligently used than in many of those broadcasts. I suppose the speaker would just send me to the well-stocked BBC Sounds archive. But it ain't the same....

Oh well, just another topic for endless grouchiness in this and other outlets. Further miserabilist rants are in the pipeline.

Meanwhile, no. I don't have a smart speaker, and I am determined never to have one.

This post was written in spring 2023, when these blatant plugs for "smart speakers" were already annoying interruptions to listening on some BBC radio stations. One of the main culprits was BBC Radio London, but it's clear the same promos are playing out on local radio all round the UK. 

No doubt the BBC feels it has to promote itself this way because so many more people are using these voice-activated audio devices. Alongside this, more BBC radio content is being re-packaged as "podcasts" for BBC Sounds online.

Has anyone noticed how some presenters are now poking gentle fun at smart speakers?

That's what I love about the crazy BBC.